Kelsey Kleven
Zoology 152
Tuesday 1:20
4/29/03
Analyzing
for the Presence of Iron in Small Intestinal Villi
Anemia, a very
serious problem among prematurely born infants, is sometimes
caused by inadequate iron absorption by the small intestine. To better understand iron
absorption, intestinal tissue samples from newborn
rats were harvested and prepared onto slides. The standard
histochemical iron staining was quantitated by the standard hand counting method and compared to the
newer digital imaging method, ImageJ software. These
methods were compared to determine the most objective
and practical way to quantitate iron.
Hand counting allowed statistically
acceptable consistency. The time invested in
personalizing ImageJ software for the iron measurement
was more than anticipated. Iron
quantitiation required adjustment of the program for
each individual slide. Due to time constraints
and complexity of analysis, the consistency analysis of the digital imaging method was not performed.
Hand counting appears to be the most practical method
for current needs. If the relative importance
of intestinal iron measurement increases for the lab, the digital method may be more practical for future
experiments.
Introduction:
Anemia
in premature infants is currently one of the most prevalent problems in
neonatal intensive care units (Samanci et
al., 1996). In a broad sense, it
develops when there is insufficient erythropoiesis, or production of red blood
cells. Red blood cells
are made after the body senses anemia and produces a hormone called
erythropoietin. This hormone stimulates
bone marrow stem cells to become red blood cells (Lappin, 1996). These red blood cells must then survive,
multiply, incorporate iron and produce hemoglobin, the oxygen-carrying component
of blood. Often there are multiple
reasons why anemia occurs. One reason is
inadequate iron absorption in the small intestine (Kling and Winzerling, 2002).
The
majority of the body’s iron is absorbed by cells lining the first portion of
the small intestine, an area known as the duodenum (Andrews, 1999). The tubular small intestine has, long, finger-like projections approximately 1mm in length known as
villi which protrude into its center and improve absorption by increasing the
surface area (Roy and Enns, 2000). (See
Figure 1)
To
better study iron absorption in premature infants, the Kling lab is planning to
quantify intestinal iron content in newborn rats fed different forms and
different amounts of iron. In one group, the pups are dam fed. In the other group, the pups receive rat milk
substitute (RMS) diet. The purpose of
having these two groups is to study the differences in iron status depending on
the source of the diet. Several measures
of iorn status are employed; i.e. plasma iron, red cell iron, and tissue iron
(Dubuque et al, 2002). After experimental feeding, intestinal
tissues will be harvested and prepared on microscope slides. These slides will be stained for iron and
evaluated either microscopically (hand counting) or digitally to quantify the
iron content in the small intestinal villi.
Hand
counting is the standard method used when analyzing tissue slides. However, the process is very time consuming,
subjective, and error-prone. When hand
counting, the number of villi stained positively for iron, i.e. blue, and the
number of individual lining cells that contain blue stain within each villi
will be counted. Some cells or regions of a villi are densly blue, where other cells or regions of
the same villi contain a speck of blue, indicating very little iron. Currently, it is difficult to quantify this
varying degree of iron staining. Hence,
digital imaging methods are being investigated.
Digital methods are available and being used in scientific literature in
other research labs on campus and elsewhere (Ruifrok, 1997).
Digital
methods potentially provide a more objective and precise measurement of a
visually-displayed image. ImageJ,
version 1.29, is an open source image processing application written in Java by
Wayne Rasband of the National Institute of Mental Health in Bethesda
Maryland. Versions of ImageJ exist for
Linux, Windows, and Macintosh platforms (Rasband, 2003). ImageJ can display, edit, analyze, process,
save, and print 8-bit, 16-bit and 32-bit images. It can read many different imaging formats
including TIFF, GIF, and JPEG, and is capable of measuring distances and
angles, scaling, rotating, flipping, and has eight levels of
magnification. Also, ImageJ allows
contrast enhancement, density profiling, sharpening, edge detecting, and for
pixel measurements to be calibrated in units such as micrometers. Examples of its use include adjusting
histogram values for color image analysis and density measurements (Ruifrok,
1997, Furness et al, 1997, Goldfarb,
2001). Furthermore, a region of interest
(ROI) within the image can be user-defined so that only significant regions
will be analyzed. Most importantly,
however, it allows for users to create plug-ins in Java to perform complex
operations on images opened in ImageJ (Rasband, 2003, Research Services Branch,
2003). A plug-in is a series of
commands, which the program and computer reads and interprets to perform
certain desired functions. In the case
of imaging programs, plug-ins can be written to repeat the same function
multiple times, each time with a different image file (Rasband, 2003). Plug-ins can be a great time saver and allow
users to develop their tools and commands specific to their project. They greatly expand the capabilities of any
imaging program.
It
is my intention to compare the degree of iron staining using microscopic hand
counting versus digital imaging software to develop an accurate and efficient
way to quantify the amount of iron absorbed.
Thus, I will quantify the proportion of villi staining positive for iron
and the proportion of individual cells within each villi staining positive for
iron and then determine the degree of iron-staining. Based on the advanced capabilities of digital
imaging programs, I hypothesized that ImageJ would be more feasible than hand
counting. I predicted that it will
require less time, will not induce the fatigue associated with manual counting,
and that the increased precision will out way any disadvantages observed.
Materials
and Methods:
This
research project is under the guidance and supervision of Dr. Pamela Kling of
the Department of Pediatrics and Division of Neonatology at Meriter
Hospital. She is also an assistant
professor with the University of Wisconsin - Madison and bases her research
work at the University of Wisconsin Hospital.
Archived
tissue iron stains produced from previous Kling lab experiments examining the
GI tract of neonatal rats were used to compare the two different methods of
quantification. These samples were taken sometime within the past two years and
stored. The slides came from experiments
which span the range of potential experimental iron feeding. These slides were made after harvesting the
segments of small intestine from experimental animals. Two-centimeter tubular sections of the small
intestine were cut, opened and fixed using paraformaldehyde to preserve the
tissues. After fixing, tissues were
mounted on paraffin blocks and sliced very thin (approximately 2 mm) with a
microtome. (Dvorak et al, 2000) The slides were then stained for iron using
Gomori’s Method which contains Hydrochloric Acid and Potassium Ferrocyanide
(Luna, 1968).
First,
hand counting by a Zeiss light microscope was used to view the slides, and a
five chamber, Fisher Scientific Cell Counter was used to track the number of
cells analyzed. While analyzing slides,
the reader was blind as to which sample was in question as a way to avoid
unwanted bias. When applying this method,
each slide was read three times.
The
first reading counted the total number of villi on that particular slide. When counting villi, strict rules were
developed and followed to eliminate subjectivity and discrepancies. These are as follows:
1.) Only count whole villi. This is important because sometimes the villi
are sectioned into smaller segments making it nearly impossible to determine
which segments are a part of which villi.
Also, villi may be cut at different angles giving an inaccurate and
inconsistent sample. Another important
thing consideration is that depending on the part of the small intestine being
analyzed, villi lengths greatly vary.
Therefore, the counter must familiarize him or her self with the length
of villi corresponding with the source and not count incomplete villi. The villi tip is crucial when looking for
iron because most absorption takes place in the tips of villi. (See figure 2)
2.) Do not count free-floating villi
unless they represent a whole villi. This means that they must be the approximate
length of a villi and also contain the actual tip of
that villi. (See figure 3)
The purpose of getting an initial villi
count is to get a base number for determining the percentage of villi
containing iron.
After
counting villi, we determined whether cells are stained positive for iron, i.e.
blue. If there was no visible iron, that
slide was labeled as negative. The
positively stained villi were counted, evaluated, and classified into three
different categories. A
villi was reported as having 1-25% of its cells stained blue, 25-75% of
its cells stained blue, or 75-100% of its cells stained blue. These categories were further labeled at +1,
+2, or +3. If there were no intestinal
endothelial cells stained blue, it was labeled as +0. The third time the slide was read, an
evaluation was made to quantify the number of villi positive for visible iron
within the intravillous space. (See
Table 1) Once the slide had been read
and counted for iron, it was given an overall ranking depicting its degree of
iron absorption. Each slide containing
visible iron was labeled as +0, +1, +2, or +3 as well as positive or negative
for iron in the intravillous space.
The
comparison (digital) method visualized the same slides with a Nikon -Eclipse
TE2000U inverted microscope with Plan Flour lenses. Next, a Diagnostic Instruments Inc. -Spot
Insight QE cooled color camera was used and the images were captured with
Diagnostic Instruments Inc. -Spot Advanced software v3.5.6 for Windows. The pictures were taken at the lab of Dr.
Jing Zheng of Meriter and saved on either a Zip disk or CD-R. The pictures were then transferred onto a iMac G4 and analyzed using ImageJ, version 1.29.
To
use ImageJ, two plug-ins were developed to perform the
analysis. The first plug-in, named
IronTest_.java, detects iron concentrations, accented
by shades of blue, in the villi and turns those areas white. The rest of the image is then turned black to
accent the contrast between iron concentrated and areas without iron content. The plug-in also calculates the percentage of
iron area in relation to the total image area.
Regions of interest (ROI) are also supported. The user can select an area of the image to
perform the analysis on. The plug-in
then ignores the rest of the image and only analyzes the ROI.
The
villi images are stored as RGB tiff files.
Each pixel contains 8 bits of red, 8 bits of blue, and 8 bits of
green. Each 8 bits can specify one of up
to 256 shades. Thus the number of colors
available for each pixel is 256 x 256 x 256 = 16,777,216, enough colors to
represent every visible color in the spectrum.
First,
the IronTest code calculates the height and width (in pixels) of the image and
checks to see if a Region of Interest (ROI) is defined. A ROI allows for the user to specify exactly
which part of each image is important and needs analysis. In analyzing for the presence of iron, a ROI
is necessary because each picture is of part of a whole slide, which has
irrelevant areas. The plug-in works as
follows:
1. For each pixel, the IronTest plug-in
stores three variables - the degree of red, green, and blue. The research done by Ruifrok is similar in
that he also worked with color ananlysis using RGB values (Ruifrok, 1997).
2. If the amount of red in a pixel is
below a specified threshold, the amount of green is below a specified
threshold, and the amount of blue is above a specified threshold, the pixel is
turned to white. Otherwise, the pixel is
turned to black. The thresholds can be
manipulated to accurately represent the presence of iron. However, because no two pictures are the
same, different threshold values must be determined for each individual
picture. The desired thresholds for each
picture are determined through trial-and-error and comparing an actual picture
with the white-on-black result.
3. Counters add up the number of white
pixels and the number of black pixels.
Once all the pixels are turned either white or black, the percentage of
the image or ROI containing iron can be calculated and displayed in a pop-up window.
4. The produced black and white picture
can then be saved and compared to the original image.
The
second plug-in developed for this project is named IronTestBatch_.java and
allows for batch analysis of images. A
user must create a text file that lists all images to be analyzed and save the
text file in the same directory that the images are stored. When running the plug-in from within ImageJ,
a box pops up giving the user the opportunity to select the text file to be
used. The IronTestBatch code works very
similar to the IronTest code.
1. The code reads the text file defined
by the user.
2. For each image defined in the file, it
calculates the percentage of blue pixels and writes the value into a results
window.
The logic for determining which pixels
are blue and which ones are not is identical to the IronTest code except that
the IronTestBatch code does not actually show the white-on-black images. The IronTestBatch only determines if the
pixel is blue (according to the specified standards for each individual
picture) and counts the number of blue and non-blue pixels.
Data
analysis:
The
data of nine slides counted three times each were analyzed by Statview, version
5, and are expressed as mean ± 2 standard deviations (95 % confidence
intervals) when assessing precison. Many
assays used in research laboratories utilize a cutoff of 5% coefficent of
variation to assess rejection for insufficient precision (PJ Kling, 2003). Coefficients of variation were then utilized
to determine the precision between results with hand counting. The coefficient of variation represents an
average deviation from the mean (Statview, 1999). To obtain the data and a mean, each slide was
counted blindly in triplicate.
Analysis
of variance (ANOVA) was used to determine if differences in percent of the villi
positive for iron between experimental treatments could be observed with hand
counting of each slide once. ANOVA
determines the significance of the factors in a model by calculating how much
the variability can be explained by those factors. When examining differences between treatment
groups, data are expressed by the mean ± two standard deviations of the mean.
Results:
Of
the nine representative slides examined (A - I), I counted between 50 ± 4 villi
on a slide to as many as 230 ± 31 villi on each 2 cm length of small intestine
on each slide. Blinded counting of the
same slides yielded a coefficient of variation range from between 0.021 to
0.634. See Table 2 for display of all coefficients of variation.
When
counting the percent of the villi positive for iron in representative slides in
triplicate, I observed between 1.2 ±2 % to 69 ± 19% of
the villi to be positive. See Figure 4
for graphic display of 9 different slides (A - I). The coefficient of variation ranged from
0.138 to the highest coefficient of variation to .867. See Table 2 for coefficients of variation.
When the percent of blue staining was statistically anaylized, most of the
coefficients of variation were inside the usual limits for acceptance. In repetitive assays, acceptable coefficients
of variations are usually <15% or .150, but when the mean number is close to
zero, higher numbers are acceptable (40% or .400) (Chard, 1990). Additionally, low coefficients of variation
were observed when evaluating the precision with scoring of 0, 1+, 2+, 3+ and
intravillous staining, as shown in table 2. Each slide was completely assessed
and recorded in a worksheet within 15-20 minutes.
To
determine whether the manual method was sufficient to discriminate differences
between treatment groups after a single counting, I examined another set of
slides with 4 different treatments, 5 different rats from each treatment group
(total of 20 rats). These included RMS control, RMS plus enteral iron, dam fed
and dam fed plus enteral iron. The findings are shown in Figure 5. There were
statistically significant differences between treatment groups by ANOVA
(p<0.0001), with dam fed and dam fed with iron differing from the RMS
control group. A post hoc test was also performed
on this set of data to show whether or not the results corresponding with each
treatment group are statistically different from each other; in other words, to
show that the differences in treatment groups are not due to chance.
Due
to time constraints and the complexity of the project, the statistical results
obtained from the digital imaging method are incomplete. However, the time to required to
learn and obtain proficiency with the microscope and camera was 2 hours. To
learn the language and write the plug-ins took approximately another 16 hours
of combined effort with a consultant who has experience with other types of
computer programming and imaging. After
the plug-ins were designed, they had to be
applied.
To begin analysis of a single 2cm length of intestine,
the slide required scanning
into 7 discreet images. This process required twenty-five minutes. Some images required re-scanning as a result
of unforeseen difficulties. Transforming
the seven images into the white-on-black image required a total of 140 minutes
and a sophisticated computer (Macintosh with OS 10 capabilities). After reporting the time required and
complexity of these analyses to Dr. Kling, she suggested to terminate the
assessment of precision with the digital counting methods.
Discussion:
When
comparing hand counting slides and using a digital method, both methods have
advantages and disadvantages.
Disadvantages of hand counting include that it’s variable and causes
physical fatigue and eyestrain that comes with looking into a microscope for
extended periods of time. However, hand
counting had its advantages. The most
significant advantages was that hand counting is
easily taught and learned in a one-on-one setting. Another very important advantage of hand
counting is that it acknowledges the presence of iron within the intravillous
space which might be especially valuable information with future studies.
Using
a digital method and imaging program was more precise and less prone to
subjectivity. However, it too had
disadvantages. First of all, writing
plug-ins was time consuming and required much extra work and knowledge. Second, only one region of interest (ROI)
could be defined at a time. This means
that only one villi could be accurately analyzed at a
time. A third disadvantage was that the
RGB threshold values were determined by trial-and-error for each picture
separately. This was also time-consuming
and made it difficult to analyze more than one picture at a time. Another important disadvantage of using a
digital method was that is not possible to calculate the total percentage of
blue villi on a slide because an entire tissue sample cannot be analyzed at one
time. Instead, each slide had to be
analyzed in multiple segments and the overlap of these segments had to be
eliminated.
The
major objective of this project was to develop a more feasible method to use
when analyzing slides compared to the standard hand counting method. In particular, we were investigating the
practicality of learning and using a digital imaging method. ImageJ is a great
program with seemingly unlimited possibilities provided one has the resources
to take advantage of all the program has to offer. However, for the purposes of the Kling lab,
the disadvantages associated with ImageJ were too significant for it to be used
as the primary method for analyzing the iron content in the small intestinal
villi. Much more time will be required
to further develop an efficient method to do the necessary analysis. This time includes educating ourselves on
further use of ImageJ and learning to write successful plug-ins. Currently, the research being done in the
Kling lab does not require the accuracy of which ImageJ is capable. For example, the primary endpoint within
their research on anemia comes from other sources; tissue iron concentration is
a secondary quantification. Also, based
on our archived slides, the differences in staining from each treatment group
being studied were great enough that they were seen without extensive analysis. However, if in future studies more subtle
differences are seen between treatment groups being analyzed and a more precise
analysis is needed, ImageJ would be more feasible and a more worthwhile
investment.
Hand
counting, on the other hand, served all the same necessary purposes that ImageJ
did without the added costs and time commitment. The results obtained from hand counting are
more general (i.e. +1, +2, +3), but for the purpose intended, the results were
acceptible. Because of this, hand
counting is definitely a practical route provided the iron content in the small
intestinal villi is not the primary experimental outcome. Our hypothesis was not supported by our data.
The
results from this project will be used when making decisions as to the most
practical way to quantify iron in the small intestinal villi. By determining exactly how much iron stains
positive with respect to each treatment, connections can be made as to the
influence of diet, iron supplement and rhEpo therapy on iron absorption. If there is little or no iron staining within
the villi, it could mean that the iron has been quickly absorbed, which can be
confirmed by high plasma iron levels which will have already been obtained,
which may be the case with rhEpo therapy (PJ Kling, 2003).
Understanding
the role rhEpo treatment and iron supplementation play in treating anemia
provides an endless opportunity for more extensive research. In particular, future research will examine
what happens to the iron once it has been absorbed. The data generated from this project will aid
in understanding the role of iron supplementation in improving anemia in
premature infants and aid the design of additional projects in this important
field.
References:
Al-Manhal International
School. Work of the small intestine [Online]. http://www.humanbody.jubilee.edu. [April 24, 2003].
Andrews NC. 1999.
Disorders of iron metabolism. New Eng. J. of Med. 341:1986-1995
Chard T.
1990. Laboratory Techniques in
Biochemistry and Molecular Biology.
El Sevier, Amsterdam-New York-Oxford: 216-219.
Dubuque SH, Dvorak B,
Woodward SS, McCuskey RS, and Kling PJ. 2002. Iron-deficient erythropoiesis in neonatal
rats. Biol. Neonate. 81:51-57
Dvork B, McWilliam DL,
Williams CS, Dominguez JA, Machen NW, McCuskey RS, and Philipps AF.
2000. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr.
31:118-120.
Furness PN,
Rogers-Wheatley L, and Harris KP. 1997.
Semiautomatic quantification of macrophages in human renal biopsy
specimens in proteinuric states. Jour of Clin Path. 50(2):118-122.
Goldfarb MF. 2001.
Analysis of casein using two-dimensional electrophoresis, western blot,
and computer imaging. Adv in Exp Med and Biol. 501:535-539.
Kling PJ.
2003. Assistant Professor &
M.D. Department of
Pediatrics, Division of Neonatology, Meriter Hospital, Madison, WI 53715. Pers. comm.
Kling PJ, and
Winzerling JJ. 2002. Iron status and the treatment of the anemia
of prematurity. Clin Perinatol. 29:283-294.
Lappin TRJ, and
Rich IN. 1996. Erythropoietin – the first 90 years. Clin Lab Haem.
18:137-145.
Luna LG.
1968. Manual of Histological
Staining Methods of the Armed Forces Institutes of Pathology. McGraw-Hill Book Company, New
York-Toronto-London-Sydney:179.
Rasband WS. Research Service Branch of National Institute of Mental Health. ImageJ [Online]. http://rsb.info.nih.gov/ij/. [March 29, 2003]
Research Services
Branch of National Institute of Mental Health.
About NIH image [Online]. http://rsb.info.nih.gov/nih-image/about.html
[Feb.15, 2003].
Roy CN, and Enns
CA. 2000. Iron homeostasis: new tales from the
crypt. Blood. 96:4020-4027.
Ruifrok AC. 1997.
Quantification of immunohistochemical staining by color translation and
automated thresholding. Anal & Quant Cytol &
Histol. 19(2):107-112.
Samanci N, Ovali F, and
Dagoglu T. 1996.
Effects of recombinant human erythropoietin in infants with very low
birth weights. J. of Int. Med. Research. 24:190-198.
Statview.
1999. Statview Reference. SAS, USA:
79-80, 84-86.
Table
1. Hand Counting Classifications
|
|
0% of cells blue |
1-25% of cells blue |
25-75% of cells blue |
75-100% of cells blue |
Blue Lumen |
|
Significance |
the lumen contains visible iron |
the lumen may or may not contain
visible iron |
the lumen may or may not contain
visible iron |
the lumen may or may not contain
visible iron |
the endothelial cells may or may not
contain visible iron |
|
Classification |
+0 |
+1 |
+2 |
+3 |
Positive or Negative for Iron |
Table 1. The five different classifications used when
hand counting to quantifying the degree of iron absorption in small intestinal
villi.
Table 2.
Coefficients of Variations
|
|
# Villi |
% Any Blue |
0% Blue |
1-25% Blue |
25-75% Blue |
75-100% Blue |
Positive Intravillous Space |
|
A |
.037 |
.867 |
.866 |
|
|
|
.866 |
|
B |
.222 |
.483 |
0 |
.436 |
|
|
|
|
C |
.068 |
.192 |
.133 |
|
|
|
.133 |
|
D |
.634 |
.314 |
.250 |
.866 |
|
|
.353 |
|
E |
.155 |
.138 |
.886 |
.755 |
.201 |
.284 |
.175 |
|
F |
.049 |
.254 |
0 |
.204 |
|
|
|
|
G |
.021 |
.224 |
.217 |
|
|
|
.217 |
|
H |
.047 |
.158 |
.128 |
.271 |
|
|
.104 |
|
I |
.164 |
.311 |
.436 |
.241 |
|
|
.573 |
Table 2. Most coefficients of variation for each slide A through I are sufficiently low, indicating that there was acceptable consistency when each slide was blindly hand counted three times. For example, a value of zero indicates that there was no variation in any of the three trials and a value of .155 is 15.5% coefficient of variation.